SECTION IV Chapter 1 - Influence of Other Religious Cultures on the Ancient Hebrews Ancient Judea/Israel was strategically situated at the crossroads between powerful civilizations. Thus the people of Israel were always "along the way" for armies trying to connect the areas of Egypt, Babylon and Persia, and Rome into great empires. The Israelites were already familiar with the cultures of Egypt (from the Exodus days) and Assyria/Babylon (from their wars and later captivity.) Persian dualism spread in the area after Xerxes the Great conquered the Babylonian Empire and set the Israelite captives free. After the conquest by Alexander the Great of the ancient world (whose borders extended from Egypt in the south through Israel and Persia, up through the Greek states into Germany and India) there was an intermingling of religious concepts. Religious ideas from India (whose monks renounced all worldly pleasures in the search for their internal self) and Greek gnosticism in particular were circulated throughout the empire built by Alexander the Great. In the next sections we shall look more closely at how some of the religions of Israel's neighbors were developing, concurrent with these times--and look at possible influences these non-Jewish sources may have had on the ancient hebrews. In the interests of time, we shall only briefly look at the ancient religions of the Egyptians, the Mesopotamians, the Persians, the Indians, and last, but not least, the Greeks. Mesopotamia Mesopotamia means "land between the rivers. Located between the Tigris and Euphrates rivers, in what is today Iraq, Mesopotamia was the site of a succession of civilizations. Ancient Sumer (circa 3000 B.C.E.) was comprised of a series of small city-states, of which Ur (mentioned in the Old Testament in relation to Abraham) was the most powerful. Around 2550 B.C.E., a wave of Semitic people under the leadership of Sargon swept down and conquered the Sumerians. By 2000 B.C.E., another series of Semitic invasions in the area led to the emergence of the Babylonian empire, with Babylon as its capital. --Garden of Eden The English archeologist George Smith, when deciphering some Assyrian cuneiform tablets that he had discovered at Ninevah during the early twentieth century, discovered an older version of the Garden of Eden. It turned out that even the word "Eden" was a Sumerian word meaning "plain". This Sumerian paradise was a happy place, which was "pure, bright, and fair where the lion does not make his kill nor the work carry off the sheep". That is, until its only human occupant fell under of curse of the Sumner gods. --Babylon The Babylonians conquered Sumer around 2500 B.C.E., under King Sargon I of Akkad. When King Hammurabi extended his empire over both Akkad and Sumer in the 19th century B.C.E., the Babylonian language replaced the Sumerian language. Yet much of the older Sumarian myths and religious literature was borrowed and worked into their own legends. After declining in power, the Babylonian empire became prominent again in the seventh and sixth centuries B.C.E., especially during the reign of King Nebuchadnezzar (605-562 B.C.E.) Many of the books of the Old Testament are believed by historians to have been written down after the hebrew captivity in Babylonia (586-538 B.C.E.) Because many of the Babylonian legends appear to be older than the birth of Moses and the hebrew nation--many scholars believe that the ancient Babylonian culture impacted the hebrews. (Another view, of course, would be that the Babylonians and the hebrews "shared" a common past.) Babylonian Cosmology--Similarities and Differences with Genesis' Account Like Genesis, the Babylonian account of creation consists of seven stages: In the beginning (stated "at that time"), there existed only a deep watery chaos. Out of the bosom of this chaos came forth the gods and the formless universe. The second through fourth stages dealt with the battles between the Babylonia gods and the dragons of the chaos. Light was introduced into the universe during the battle, and finally the only task remaining was to defeat the grand dragon, Tiamat herself. Tiamat is slain and out of her skin is created the visible firmament of heaven. After the heavens were formed, the fifth stage emerges--whereby mansions for the gods were created in the form of the sun, moon and stars. During the sixth stage, the gods created earth and populated it with vegetables, birds, and fish. Described in the seventh and last phase is the creation of animals and reptiles. Although there are some similarities with the Genesis version in the creation account--such as the seven stages, and the physical creation beginning with light-- there are important differences, too.(That is, besides the obvious differences in the multiple gods compared to one God). The Babylonian account has the earth created AFTER the other heavenly bodies (sun, moon, stars). The Genesis account states the earth was created first. (See Section VIII, Chapter 3 for a discussion of this topic). The seventh day in the Babylonian account describes a day of activity. This is described as a day of rest in Genesis. According to the Babylonian creation myth, God initially created a single being made up of a man joined together with a woman. Only later were they separated into two entities--one male and the other female. In Genesis 5:2, God also appears to refer to Adam and Eve as one creature: "Male and female created He them and blessed them and called their name Adam." The Babylonians worshipped many deities, but their favorite god was Marduk. Marduk was a trinity of three gods in one--the god father Anu, the god mother Anna (also called Istar) and the son Bel. Bel-Merodach was one of the gods that fought the creation battles against the great dragon Tiamat. He was the "healer and mediator for mankind; He revealed to mankind the knowledge of Ea (the god of the sea); in all incantations he is invoked as the god 'mighty to save' against evil and ill." (Professor Budge, Babylonian Life and History, p127). Some scholars have gone so far as to describe Bel-Merodach as a Christ-like figure of the Babylonians. Others have compared the imagery of these myths with that in the book of Revelations. Despite the similarities in theme between the Babylonian and Jewish accounts of the creation, there is a major difference in style. While the Babylonian texts are polytheistic, often with sexual overtones, the hebrew version is monotheistic and "purified" of the gods/goddesses entanglements. Its greater simplicity gives it a focus that is more deep and inspiring. Thus, despite the fact that Assyria and Babylonia were considered to be the more powerful civilizations in their day--it was the more advanced hebrew religion that endured. Heaven and Hell It is an interesting fact that the earliest books of the Bible--ie the books of Moses, Judges, and Kings--never refer to a heavenlike existence where the virtuous would dwell after death.--This despite the fact, that their contemporaries, the Egyptians did believe in the achievability of an immortal soul. It would seem that the early Israelites, while purifying their sacred texts of the god/goddess myths, also classified beliefs in the afterlife as mythical. (This would change after the Israelites culture came into contact with Persian dualism during 530 B.C.E. See Section VI, Chapter 1 for more details on the ancient Judaic-Christian views of the universe.) As with the ancient hebrews, the Babylonians did not have a doctrine that promised an afterlife in heaven for the virtuous. This was not because the Babylonians did not share in the universal desire for immortality.--In the epic of Gilgamesh, this topic comes up, where a friend tries to persuade Gilgamesh that his quest for immortality is in vain: "Gilgamesh, whither are you wandering? Life, which you look for, you will never find. For when the gods created man, they let death be his share, and life withheld in their own hands. Gilgamesh, fill your belly-- day and night make merry, let every day be full of joy, dance and make music day and night. Put on clean clothes, and wash your head and bathe. Gaze at the child that is holding your hand, and let your wife delight in your embrace. These things alone are the concern of men." The Babylonians described their version of Hell in a narrative which has a goddess descend into hell in search of her young husband. The land of death is described as a dreary place where there is no light, and where the spirits live off dust for food and mud for meat. The Old Testament refers to the afterlife as "Sheol", also called the pit, in a manner that seems similar to the Babylonian version. Divine Punishment for Wickedness Sometimes Visited on Later Generations It was a common belief in Mesopotamia that the gods would punish all of society if they were neglected. The punishment might not be immediate.--The sinner might be allowed to live a prosperous life while later generations "paid" the price. (Footnote: The Hittites civilization (which existed centuries before the Old Testament) had also written on their struggle to understand this divine policy. THE ORIGINS OF HISTORY. Herbert Butterfield, p 161) Likewise, ancient hebrews believed that later generations could be held accountable by God for the sins of their FATHERS--as far down as the third and fourth generation. This is explicitly stated within the introduction to the Ten Commandments: "Thy Lord thy God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children to the third and the fourth generation of those who hate me." (Exodus 20:5) --The Flood The land of Mesopotamia was a flat alluvial plain laid down by the Tigris and the Euphrates rivers. Unlike the Nile in Egypt whose inundations were cyclical and predictable, flooding was often both violent and unpredictable. The early Sumerian myths tell of a great Flood unleashed by a god. This earlier story of a flood was borrowed and elaborated on by the Babylonians, into at least two versions. In one version, the hero is named Atrahasis (meaning "the exceedingly wise"). In the other version, the hero is identified as Gilgamesh, who was a king in southern Babylonia. In all these versions of the flood, one of the gods becomes angry and determines to destroy the earth with a flood. (Unlike in the Genesis version, the god is NOT angry because the people have sinned--but instead is angered because human civilization was too noisy--making it difficult for him to sleep.) Another god comes to the rescue by directing one man to built a large boat to save his family and the animals from the ensuing flood. The Genesis version is believed to be more recent--dated by many scholars from around the 10th century B.C.E. One interesting similarity between the Genesis flood story and the older Sumarian/Babylonian versions, is that both tell how a dove was used to detect land. In the EPIC OF GILGAMESH, this scene is narrated as follows: "For a fifth day and a sixth day the mountains of Nisir held up the ship and did not let it waver. When the seventh day came, I sent forth a dove and let it loose. The dove flew away and shortly returned; she had seen no resting place and so she came back." (Of course, although the story of Noah's ark also employs a dove in a similar manner, possibly this was just a coincidence--That is, sending doves out from boats, as a test for land, may have been a common practice throughout this area of the ancient world.) --King Sargon of Akkad Babylon's greatest hero and king, was Sargon I of Akkad--who conquered the area of Mesopotamia around 2500 B.C.E. According to ancient legends, Sargon's mother saved her baby's life by hiding him in a basket of reeds which was then placed upon the Euphrates river. Downstream, Sargon was found by a peasant who raised Sargon as his own son. Sargon was eventually helped by the goddess Ishtar, to become ruler of his nation. (Many historians, noting the strong similarities with the story of Moses, believe the legend of Sargon's birth existed for hundreds of years, long before Moses reportedly led the Israelites out of Egypt--around 1300 B.C.E.) --Ten Commandments and Hammurabi's Code In addition, archeologists have noted a strong similarity between the Old Testament story of how Moses received the Ten Commandments on tablets of stone from God and the story of the Code of Hammurabi (discovered in 1902). Hammurabi, a Babylonian king, lived around 1728-1686 B.C.E.,( which scholars believe to have been some four hundred years before Moses lived). These laws were held to be of divine origin. Today, the steele containing Hammarbi's code resides in the Louvre Museum in Paris, France). The upper panel of Hammurabi's Code shows the king Hammurabi, with a long beard and turban-- receiving the divine tablets of law from the sun god, Shamash. The introduction to the laws sounds surprisingly progressive-- stating that its purpose was to "bring forth the victory of righteousness, and thereby prevent the strong from unjustly prevailing over the weak... and to instruct the nation and to further the well-being of the people." Some of Hammurabi's laws also show some similarities with those of Moses. For example, in Hammurabi's code appears: "If a man shall put out the eye of another, then let his own eye be put out. If a man shall knock out the teeth of another who is higher in rank, then let his own teeth be knocked out. This idea is expressed in the Ten Commandments (Exodus 21:23-24), as "And if any mischief follow, then thou shalt give life for life, eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, foot for foot." In Hammurabi's Code, native born slaves (usually enslaved for not paying their debts) were guaranteed to be freed after three years: "Three years shall they [the non-foreign born slaves] work in the house of their buyer and in the fourth year he shall fix their liberty." Likewise, the hebrews only allowed a fellow hebrew servant to serve for six years before being freed: "If thou buy a Hebrew servant, six years shall he serve: and in the seventh he shall go out free for nothing." (Exodus 21). Perhaps the most striking comparison between Hammurabi's Code and the Mosaic laws in Exodus deal with oxen. Per Hammurabi's Code: "If an ox, walking in the street gored a freeman and caused his death, the cause is not subject ot settlement. But if the freeman's ox was a gorer and his city council had informed him that it was a gorer, and he did not paid its horns and tie up the ox, and the ox gored to death an aristocrat, he shall pay one-half mina of silver." Compared to Exodus 21:28-36: "When an ox gores a man or a woman to death the ox shall be stoned, and its flesh not be eaten; but the owner shall be clear. But if the ox has been accustomed to gore in the past, and its owner has been warned but has not kept it in, and it kills a man or a woman, the ox shall be stoned and its owner put to death also...If the ox gores a slave, male or female, the owner shall give to their master thirty shekels of silver, and the ox shall be stoned." These parallels are even more striking, because it is generally believed that oxen were NOT used by the early nomadic hebrews. (That is, oxen are used by farmers to plow tracts of land--but are not used by desert wandering nomads.) (quotes and commentary taken from Gerald A. Larue, ANCIENT MYTH AND MODERN LIFE, Centerline Press, Long Beach, California, 1988m, p 130e.) Because of these similarities, many biblical scholars believe it highly probable that Moses must have been directly or indirectly familiar with the laws in Hammurabi's Code. There were also important dissimilarities between Hammurabi's Code and the Ten Commandments. In Hammurabi's code, there are 282 different laws, which describe different penalties for the wrongdoer or victim, depending upon their social status as a priest, official, freedman, or slave. The hebrews had a more egalitarian view--whereby EVERY man and women had to obey God's laws--regardless of their social status. Of all the Babylonian laws, one of them was amazingly progressive, compared to what we have even today in modern society. This law allowed for the compensation of victims of robbery by the State: "If a robber is not taken, the city and the elders where the robbery took place shall restore everything to the householder of which he was despoiled as soon as he demands before a court that this be done" --Tower of Babel Babel was the biblical name for the city of Babylon. The inhabitants tried to build a tower so tall that it could reach heaven itself. God punished all the people by confounding their speech, creating great confusion. This is the biblical explanation of how so many different languages developed. The Babylonians were famous for building tall ziggurats, which probably was the basis for the story. Herodotus, the Greek writer described a huge, impressive ziggurat during his travels to the region about 450 B.C.E. --Babylonian New Year Festival and its Use of ScapeGoats Hebrew kings were anointed to become God's representatives on earth. ("Messiah" means anointed one). The Babylonians also viewed their kings as representatives of God on earth: Throughout Mesopotamia, the kings were considered upon their official accession to the throne--to be the ADOPTED son of God. Afterwards, they acted as a god on earth, and a representative of the people for the other gods. (John Hinnells, PERSIAN MYTHOLOGY, Peter Bedrick Books, New York, 1973, 1985, p 98) The Babylonian New Year festival (Akitu), was celebrated over a ten day period. The ENUMA, or epic of creation, was read to the people to describe a fierce battle between Marduk, the god of heaven, and Tiamat, the goddess of the deep--and symbolizing chaos. In this way, the people were reminded of how the current order of the cosmos had originally arisen out of chaos. On the fifth day of the festival, a ritual was conducted whereby a sheep was exorcised of his demons (symbolizing the removal of chaos from the community). The sheep's head was cut off, and his body was thrown into the river. Biblical scholars believe there is a similarity in this ritual, and that of the scapegoat ritual of the ancient hebrews. During the celebration of Yom Kippur, the sins of the community were transferred to a goat--which was then thrown over a cliff outside of Jerusalem into the wilderness, to rid the people of their sins. (See Leviticus 16:8-10) On the eighth day of the festival, the Babylonian king, in his role as the representative of the sinful community, submitted to ritual acts of humiliation.--His symbols of regal power were taken away during this ritual, and the priest slapped him on the face, commanding him to pray to Marduk. After this was over, the king's royal insignia were restored, and other ceremonies were conducted to ensure the continuation of order over chaos. The people celebrated in a carnival like atmosphere during the period when the sheep was beheaded, and the king was absolved of the sins of the people. Afterward the king was reinstated by the priest, the mood shifted to formal ceremonies, that lead to a procession for believers to a sanctuary outside the city. On the tenth day, a banquet was held by the king and priests to celebrate the redemption of the people before the gods. --Babylonian Parallel to Job, the Faithful Servant of God The ancient Babylonians believed that the gods controlled the destiny of individuals/nations. The mark of a good man was obedience to societal and religious laws. Babylonian wisdom texts often emphasized the virtues of prudence, modesty, and the avoidance of hostility. Sin, the violation of the divine will, could be atoned for through sacrifice and prayer. Some Babylonian poems are composed as passionate cries from believers, who failed to understand why sometimes the virtuous suffered. For example, in one Babylonian poem, there is a dialogue between a suffering religious man, and his friend. The religious man asks why those who worship the gods often suffer--while those who are wicked, often prosper? "How have I profited", he asks his friend, "that I have bowed down to my God?" There is no real solution given in the poem. The man's friend recommends that he accept his destiny in good faith. This theme is of course similar to the book of Job in the Old Testament. However, in Job's case, God was testing him to prove his loyalty. Afterwards, Job is rewarded with a long and prosperous life on earth. The Introduction of Persian Dualism The official priests of Iran were called Magi. A hereditary priest caste, the Magis were responsible for all matters of religion. In Persia, around 400-500 B.C.E., the Magis appear to have used the doctrine of dualism to explain the presence of evil in a basically good world. The term dualism is used to described the "dual" or twosome nature of the world, which results from cosmic forces of good fighting against the forces of evil. The founder of Persian dualism, Zarathustra (called Zoraster by the Greeks) traditionally lived from 628-551 B.C.E. (although some archeological evidence suggests he may have lived as early as the eleventh century B.C.E.) Zarathustra taught that the force of good was led by Ahura, the "Lord of Enlightenment". Ahura and the forces of good stood opposed to the forces of evil led by Ahriman and his demons. There were both angels and demons in the divine hierarchy. Man must align himself either with the good powers, or the dark forces. At death, every person's life is weighed in balance. If the good outweighs the bad, then the person goes to heaven. If the bad outweighs the good, the evil doer fall into the hands of the great devil, Ahriman and is doomed to hell. Those in whom good and evil are equal remain in an in-between state. (Note: Persian dualism was also discussed in Section VI, Chapter 1). Zorastrians taught that the end of the age was upon us, and that a great crisis was at hand between the forces of good and evil. In the end, a savior would come, who would conquer the evil forces and bring about a new world order. His name would be Victorius, Righteousness-incarnate, and the Savior. During this time there would be a general resurrection of the dead. After this great victory, the living and resurrected dead would be transformed into immortal beings that cast no shadows in a new world of good. Zorastrianism became the dominant religion of the people of Iran during the reign of the Persian kings Darius (522-486 B.C.E.) and Xerxes (486-465 B.C.E.) The Persian belief in the appearance of a savior (who would conquer the evil forces in the world and make men immortal) was known to the early Jews in the centuries before Jesus' birth. After the Babylonian captivity under Nebuchadrezzar in 586 B.C.E., the upper class and educated Jews were uprooted from their home country and forced to live in a foreign culture. Roughly fifty years later, the Babylonians were defeated by the Persians. The Persians allowed the Israelites to return home, and generously supplied money to allow for the rebuilding of the Temple at Jerusalem. The point is that the two cultures did meet at this time in a friendly exchange. That the Jews of this time were aware of the religion of their benefactor can been seen in the original book of Ezra which states that "Cyrus, the King, built the house of the Lord in Jerusalem, where they worship him with eternal fire." Ezra probably wrote during the reign of the Persian king Artaxerxes, who ruled from 404-358 B.C.E. Throughout history, it can be clearly demonstrated that whenever two cultures meet, there is an exposure to new ideas, including religious beliefs. Typically, whenever a conqueror imposes his "superior" religion upon the populace, some old beliefs and rites of the existing population will still remain in some form. These local native beliefs will then merge with the official religion, creating new combinations/variations of beliefs and customs. Some scholars claim that it was AFTER the encounter of Jews with Persian Dualism, that Judaism was transformed into a religion that believed in a local, tribal God (who was more powerful, but "jealous" over the other gods)-- into a supreme God of the universe. Jewish messianic views of a messiah with semi-divine status, who would lead the Jews towards a new Jerusalem on earth (after an apocalyptic battle between the good and evil whereby the old order of the earth is destroyed) is also believed by some scholars to have been influenced by Zorastrian dualism. This theme of an "apocalyptic" battle between the forces of good and evil is prominent in many near Eastern myths, such as the stories of Osiris and Tammuz. Buddhism During the middle of the sixth century B.C.E., at around the time Cyrus the Great had revolted from the Medes and was building Persia into a great empire, Siddharta Gautama (founder of Buddhism) was born in India. Gautama was the son of a very wealthy rajah. However, around the age of thirty, he became repulsed at the luxury he possessed, in comparison to the stark pain and poverty of most of the people. Reflecting on the pain, suffering, and death he saw around him, he determined that all life was futile. He consequently gave up his family fortune (leaving behind a beautiful wife and a young son) in order to search for truth and contentment. He wandered around the countryside for many years as a poor beggar. At first he dwelt with hermit philosophers who lived in a cave.--But he found that they spoke clever words that had no real meaning. He led five of the hermits with him out into the jungles in search of another path towards salvation. For the next six years, he gave himself up to self-mortification, striving to reach Nirvana through pain and ascetism. It was said, that during this time Gautama practiced austerities the like of which had never before been seen, such as living on a grain of rice a day, or on a single sesamum seed. However, despite all Gautama's austerity, he found his six years were "like time spent striving to tie the air into knots." He finally realized that the path of asceticism and denial would also never lead to the road to salvation. And so he set off alone, this time far unhappier than ever before. He had lived the live of a prince, a philosopher, and now an ascetic-- but could find no release for his internal suffering. Then, one day after despairing of his quest, he sat beneath a bo tree in deep meditation, determined that he would not leave until he had found salvation. Without warning, his whole being was swept up into a feeling of enlightenment. His whole spirit was suffused with ecstasy, which elevated him to a higher state where he felt released at last--released from life and the fear of death. Ignorance was gone, and knowledge and goodness stood in its place. He felt that he had completed his rebirth, and had attained the state of the enlightened one. Following his enlightenment ("Buddha" means awakened or enlightened), Gautama Buddha set out to share his experience with others. He preached the Middle Way or Path, which sought to direct living towards a middle road between self-indulgence and extreme asceticism. All followers were urged to avoid the ten immoral actions: (1) do not destroy life (2) do not take what is not given (3) abstain from unchaste acts (4) do not lie or deceive (5) do not slander (6) do not use harsh language (7) avoid frivolous talk (8) do not covet (9) avoid ill will (10) avoid false views When asked early in his career, why there was so much suffering in the world, and what could mankind do to find peace and contentment, the Buddha answered by describing his doctrine of the Four Truths: The First Truth held that both birth and death bring sadness, and that life is utterly vain: "The waters of the four great oceans are naught compared with the tears of men as they tread the path of life." Secondly, Gautama taught that the vanity of life is caused by the overindulgence of desire. (Indeed, Gautama believed that his earlier mistakes were to overindulge even in the passions of asceticism--that it was as much folly to go mad with pain, as it was to get drunk with pleasure.) Third, vanity can end only with the ending of all desire. Fourth and last, Gautama taught that desire can NOT be ended by excessive asceticism, but by living a good, virtuous life--ie through the eight noble paths of "Right Belief, Right Resolve, Right Speech, Right Action, Right Livelihood, Right Effort, Right Thought, and Right Meditation." Gautama stressed strong humanistic values in all of his doctrines--such as the importance of living one's life to help all other living creatures (humans AND animals). Buddha had argued that in focusing primarily on our material wants, that we fail to see others as equal to ourselves. Buddha urged his followers to love all mankind "with a mother's love." (See Section VI, Chapter 4 for the full quote.) Some of the Buddha's teachings are reminiscent of the teachings of Jesus on the Sermon on the Mount. For example, Buddha taught his followers "Hatred ceases by love, this is an old rule." And, "If someone curses you, you must repress all resentment." As with the Hindu philosophers, Budda considered knowledge and insight to lead toward the true path of salvation. Buddha urged his followers to break the chains which tie one to the wheel of existence. He identified ten fetters or obstacles as: (1) belief in the existence of the self or ego, (2) doubt, (3) reliance on good works, such as ascetic discipline (4) sensuality and lust, (5) ill will (6) desire for rebirth on Earth, (7) desire for rebirth in another heavenly realm, (8) pride, (9) self-righteousness, (10) ignorance. Much of the Buddha's message was considered radical: First, he taught that there were no valid social distinctions in caste between high-born and low-born, for men should instead be judged only according to their deeds. His teachings also left no room for gods, priests, and prayers. "Who is there that has ever seen Brahma [God] face to face" declared Gautama. And with regard to prayer: "Could the farther bank of the river Akirvati come over to this side no matter how much a man prayed it to do so?" The historical Buddha denied the separate existence of a soul for one's body (unlike the Hindu and later Greek philosophers of his time). He claimed the soul to be no more than a name for the totality of human desires. He gave the analogy of a chariot-- which is made up of wheels, shaft, axle, carriage, etc. Just as there is no real existence of a chariot when these are all removed, so the soul is made up of desires and other psychic frames of mind, that disappears when all its components are taken away. Thus, it followed that transmigration of souls did not exist. Only the deeds, not the doers, continue on from one generation to the next. To Buddha, holding onto this notion of a permanent "soul" leads to an egocentric view of the world--an artificial division of the world between "me" and everything else. One must abandon this egocentric view of the world in order to enter into a freer, happier realm of existence, which is nirvana. Per Buddha, the Law of Karma (an inevitable and powerful "law of deed" ) operated within the universe, and was the mechanism through which righteous men could throw off their chains to attain the blessed release of Nirvana. Those who were burdened with desire--either for material possessions or to be born again, will experience rebirth through karma, and thus continue in the chain of suffering. The wise, who lose their desire for rebirth "are extinguished at death like a lamp." (Ibid., p 61) (Over time however, many sects within Buddhism interpreted nirvana as a heaven-like existence, and a reward for a virtuous life.) Scholars have pointed out that the original form of Buddhism was more interested in morality and ethics than a universal cosmology. Indeed, there is no Supreme Deity behind the Buddha's original doctrines and morality. The universe always existed--without beginning and without end. All life that dwells in the universe is constantly changing from one form into another through repetitive cycles moving from birth into death. For the first centuries, Buddhism remained a relatively small and unimportant sect among many other small sects in India. Gradually, some of the rajahs of India converted to Buddhism, partly because they saw its value in wrestling control from the hands of the long-dominant priestly caste. In the middle third century B.C.E., the powerful King Asoka expanded his large Buddhist empire into northern India. Before converting to Buddhism he was reportedly a ruthless conqueror. After becoming a Buddhist, he repented of his violent wars--and became a gentle ruler who built temples, schools, and likewise provided for the needs of his subjects. He also banned the royal hunt, as he now believed it wrong to kill animals. Asoka reportedly sent missionaries out all over the known ancient world--from Burma and Thailand in the East, to Greece, Egypt, and possibly even the near East (including Palestine). Some scholars believe Buddhist monks may have been active even as late as the first century C.E. in Palestine and Greece. Roughly the same time, Buddhist monks successfully converted some of the brahmans who lived in the Greco-Roman culture in the kingdom of Bactria (which is located today on the northwest borders of West Pakistan.) Roughly five hundred years after Buddha's death, two large schools of Buddhism emerged. The Hinayana school meaning "Lesser Vehicle" (implying the use of a smaller raft or ferry to cross over the river into nirvana), was the more traditional branch of the two. The Hinayana school stressed meditation and living an ascetic lifestyle in Buddhist monasteries. One's spiritual preparation is what is considered important, instead of the material welfare of the individual. The universe is believed to be an endless changing of life from one form into another. The other school of Buddhism (called the Mahayan meaning the "Greater Vehicle"), emerged after Buddhist monks met up with the Greco-Roman culture in the kingdom of Bactria (located today on the northwest borders of West Pakistan). The converted brahmen merged their earlier beliefs with Buddhist concepts, bringing with them their speculative philosophy and cosmic themes on the origin of the universe. The Mahayan school of Buddhism claimed that Buddha was no ordinary man, but a divine god (supernaturally conceived) who had been sent down from heaven as the savior of men. Earlier traditions had spoken of Buddha being tempted by Mara when he was under the Bo tree--this was depicted more as a mental or spiritual battle. Now this later became embellished, under the Mahayan school, as a physical temptation whereby Mara offered him great wealth and the sensual pleasures of his beautiful daughters, in order to thwart his great purpose. Over the centuries, Buddhism splintered further into different sects, as various groups of monks began interpreting Buddha's doctrines along different outlooks. Mahayan Buddhists had taught that Buddha's divine spirit returned to earth, reincarnating itself in various generations inside certain exceptionally holy men called Bodhisattvas, "Living Buddhas". Anyone could be the Bodhisattva, or cosmic being who was chosen to enlighten his generation-- both laymen or monks. This form of Buddhism eventually spread to China, Korea, Japan, and Tibet. In Tibet, Mahayana Buddhism met up with other religions, (including possibly some early version of Christianity), merging into a form very different from mainstream Buddhism. Tibetian Buddhism is known as Lamaism, whose spiritual leader, the Dalai Lama, is venerated as the Bodhisattva. Another school (which refers to themselves as Theravada Buddhists, (or "teaching of the elders") worships relics and statues (such of them gigantic in size) of Buddha. Theravada Buddhism became strong in Thailand, Cambodia, Laos, Ceylon, and Burma through the efforts of missionaries. Zen and Shin Buddhism (which both originated in Japan) are the sects most popular in the West. Zen Buddhists revere a monk named Amida, who purportedly became transformed into a Buddha. He promised rebirth into another heaven-like existence, to all those who follow his doctrines. Zen Buddhists believe that each person originally existed in a state of Buddhahood. This state can only be regained by restoring one's former state of mind through a focused series of meditations and the inner experience of ultimate reality. Ironically, Buddhism became nearly extinct in India, its land of origin. By the twelfth century C.E., Hindu priests had largely won back control of the countryside. Invading Islamic armies successfully extinguished what was left of Buddhism in India. Buddhism remained strong in surrounding countries -- such as Tibet, China, Thailand, Laos and Cambodia and Japan (where it merged with Shintoism). In modern times, communists have been one of the greatest enemies to Buddhism, attempting to ruthlessly wipe out Buddhism in countries that they control, such as China, Tibet, Laos and Cambodia. Despite the persecutions, Buddhism is alive and strong, and one of the major world religions today. Proponents of Buddhism point out that it is the only world religion that has truly been characterized by gentleness and peacefulness--For its followers have typically NOT resorted to violence, persecution, inquisitions, or witch hunts against NON-believers. Critics of Buddhism maintain that the passive, ascetic attitude of the Buddhists prevents them from engaging in the sciences and technology--in an attempt to improve this world. Egyptians The ancient Egyptians possessed one of the greatest civilization known in the ancient world. The Old Testament attests to the powerful influence Egypt held on the ancient hebrews.-- Moses reportedly had been raised by an Egyptian princess. The hebrews who entered Canaan as the first "Israelites" had been raised up in Egypt, albeit as slaves. This means that the ancient hebrews should have been exposed to Egyptian beliefs and practices. The ancient Egyptians worshiped a large number of half-animal gods over the millennium, whose names and protections changed over time. Only one god, Osiris, managed to hold his place in the affections of the people throughout the long history of Egypt. Originally, Osiris was one of the gods associated with agriculture. Seeing the annual birth and rebirth of vegetation each year with the clockwork precision of the seasons, Osiris later began to be associated with rebirth and resurrection. The tale was told how Osiris, the god of nurturing Light and Good, was treacherously murdered by Set, the god of withering Darkness and Evil. When Osiris' wife, Isis discovered the murder, she searched up and down the land to find the body of her husband. Her tears during her search, accumulated into the Nile and caused it to overflow its banks. She finally found the body and buried it. But while attending her fatherless son, Horus, the evil Set found the body of Osiris. He cut it into pieces, hiding each fragment in a different place. Isis thus set out a second time, traversing the land until she had found all the pieces-- This time she safely buried her husband's body in a sealed tomb. Miraculously Osiris was resurrected from death, and taken into heaven. In heaven, it was believed that Osiris acted as Judge, whereby if a human had lived a moral life, then his spirit would dwell in heaven with him for eternity. Believing in dualism (that a spirit resides within the human body, which is released upon death), Egyptian theologians taught that upon death, the soul set out on a perilous journey, whereby evil spirits tried to intercept them. If the soul had been adequately provided with magical spells, then it could pass through all these hurdles, and glide safely to Judgment Hall in heaven, before the celestial throne of the Judge and god, Osiris. There the soul had to give a moral account of itself before Osiris and forty-two associate gods. If the soul could truly say: "I come before ye without sin, and have done that wherewith the gods are satisfied. I have not slain, nor robbed, nor stirred up strife, nor lied nor lost my temper, nor committed adultery, nor stolen temple food...I have given bread to the hungry, clothes to the naked, a ferry to him who had no boat" --then the soul went straightway to heaven. (The heart of the deceased is often represented as weighed by the jackal-headed god Anubis against the symbol of Maat--Truth and Order--while accounting for their past moral life before the presence of Osiris.) If the person did not lead a moral life, then its soul was either cast back down to earth, where it was reincarnated in some other low form such as a pig, or thrown into a terrible hell. In the early dynasties, it was believed that only Egyptian kings had souls, and therefore had any opportunity for resurrection. During these times, only Egyptian kings were embalmed and mummified, and then entombed within huge pyramids. Gradually, centuries later, the promise of immortality was extended to all people--not just kings. During these later periods, therefore, anyone who could afford the mummification that could house its human body did so. Some animals that were believed to be divine (such as cats, crocodiles, bulls and rams) were accorded a soul, and mummified in the hopes that they too would be resurrected. So many cats were mummified during this period, that the cemetery at Beni Hasan has been used in the twentieth century as a quarry for fertilizer. A passage from the Egyptian BOOK OF THE DEAD tells of one dead soul giving the testimony of his earthly life within the Hall of Truth, to Ma the goddess of truth. Kneeling, the departed calls out the names of the forty-two Egyptian gods. He swears to each one individually that he has lived a life of purity, by pledging the following (Note: The names of the Egyptian assessors are omitted here for simplicity): I have not done evil. I have not robbed with violence. I have not stolen. I have done no murder; I have done no harm. I have not defrauded the offerings [of the gods] I have not diminished oblations. I have not plundered the god. I have spoken no lies. I have not snatched away food. I have not caused pain. I have not committed fornication. I have not caused shedding of tears. I have not dealt deceitfully. I have not transgressed. I have not acted guilefully. I have not laid waste the ploughed land. I have not been an eavesdropper. I have not set my lips in motion [against another] I have not been angry and wrathful except for a just cause. I have not defiled the wife of any man. I have not defiled the wife of any man [ie this line is repeated here] I have not polluted myself. I have not caused terror. I have not transgressed. I have not burned with rage. I have not stopped my ears against the words of Right and Truth. I have not worked grief. I have not acted with insolence. I have not stirred up strife. I have not judged hastily. I have not been an eves dropper. I have not multiplied words exceedingly. I have done neither harm nor ill. I have never cursed the king. I have never fouled the water. I have not spoken scornfully. I have never cursed God. I have not stolen. I have not defrauded the offerings of the gods. I have not plundered the offerings to the blessed dead. I have not filched the food of the infant, neither have I sinned against the god of my native town. I have not slaughtered with evil intent the cattle of the gods. (E.A. Wallis Budge, THE EGYPTIAN BOOK OF THE DEAD--(THE PAPYRUS OF ANI) EGYPTIAN TEXT TRANSLITERATION AND TRANSLATION, Dover Publications, Inc, New York, 1967 which is a republication of the original work published in 1895 under the Trustees of the British Museum, Plates XXXI. AND XXXII. [The Negative Confession], pp 347-9) The similarities between the moral code embodied in the Egyptian BOOK OF THE DEAD and the TEN COMMANDMENTS of the Hebrews are striking. Both moral laws contain exhortations against stealing, murder, fornication, bearing false witness against one's neighbor, or cursing God. Missing from the BOOK OF THE DEAD are the commandments to honor one's father and mother, and not to covet [desire] our neighbors' possessions. There is also no mention of a "jealous" God in the BOOK OF THE DEAD who commands that no other gods are to be worshiped, no graven images made, and that a sabbath is to be observed for His worship. There are some commandments in the Egyptian BOOK OF THE DEAD which are humane, and arguably good moral commandments for mankind--but which do not appear in the TEN COMMANDMENTS. For example, there are exhortations against not being angry or wrathful without just cause, not causing violence, not causing harm to others, and even not causing any one to weep. Modern day environmentalists would be pleased if they had the biblical authority of a Ten Commandments to urge the faithful to never "foul" the water, or to "filch the food of the infant". According to the religious beliefs in the Egyptian BOOK OF THE DEAD, the departed one placed his heart on the balance of truth, where it was weighed by the Egyptian gods Hor and Anubis. If it was announced that the weight of the heart was equal to truth, then the heart was placed back into the chest of the departed one, restoring it to life. He was then allowed to enter "the boat of the sun" and was taken to the Elysian fields of the blessed. While the physical body remained in the tomb, the soul, represented as a bird with a human head, soared to heaven. There it became one with the great gods. Should the weighing of the heart find that evil deeds outweighed their good deeds, the departed was devoured by a great beast, or else returned to the earth in the shape of a despised animal, such as a pig. (A pig was considered unclean by Egyptians just as it was to the hebrews.) Amulets and magical incantations were sold which purportedly protected the initiate during his spiritual journey to the next world. The magical incantations were believed to achieve power by calling out a god's special name. Interestingly, the ancient hebrews also ascribed a mystical reverence in pronouncing the name of Yahweh, or God. For this reason, Yahweh's full name did not appear in the sacred texts, and only a holy priest was allowed to pronounce it. Monotheism Pharoah Amonhotep (c 1350 B.C.E.), was the first to introduce a state religion based on one God--Aton, the god of the sun. He gave up his original name Amonhotep because it contained the name of the old god, Amon. He also renamed himself Akhnaton, which meant "Spirit of Aton". The Hymn to the one God Aton contains poetical tributes to the goodness of Aton--which some scholars believe have strong parallels to Psalms 104 of the Old Testament. Some have speculated that Moses may have been exposed to this religion when he lived in Egypt. Regardless of one's views on this, the hebrews made an important improvement on Akhenaten's one God. For they conceived of him as a TRANSCENDENT, immaterial being--whose spirit and awareness is EVERYWHERE--as opposed to confined to a single aspect of nature, such as the sun. Akhaton's monotheism was short lived. Upon his death, the Egyptian priests quickly regained control, and Egypt reverted back to polytheism. Biblical References to the ancient Hebrews' Journey From Egypt to the "Promised Land" Below are Old Testament stories that deal with the ancient hebrews' exodus from Egypt, and their journey into Canaan (or Promised Land). --The Exodus of Hebrews out of Egypt Under Moses According to Exodus 12:37, "And the children of Israel journeyed from Ramses to Succoth, about six hundred thousand on foot that were men, beside children." Taking this passage literally, would mean that there was roughly some million Israelites who had left Egypt after counting women and children. A million people is such a hugh number--that if this many people marched in a single column, it would be SIXTY miles long. The desert would obviously not be able to support such a huge gathering, which is why the bible talks about the miraculous food of manna being provided by God. But there is another possibility as well. According to Manfred Barthel on this subject, large numbers "...are not necessarily what they seem. The word ELEF ordinarily means "thousand", [in Hebrew] but it also has the secondary meaning of "clan", or as we would say today, "extended family". This is perhaps what the authors of Exodus had in mind--that six hundred families followed Moses out of Egypt, which also might explain why the Egyptian chroniclers didn't bother to waste even a single hieroglyph on the disappearance from their midst of a few hundred miserable nomads." (Ibid, p 112) --The Crossing of the Red Sea According to Exodus 14:21-22, 28 "...and the LORD caused the sea to go back by a strong east wind all that night, and made the sea dry land, and the waters were divided. "And the children of Israel went into the midst of the sea upon the dry ground... "And the waters returned, and covered the chariots, and the horsemen, and all the host of Pharaoh that came into the sea after them; there remained not so much as one of them." In some recent translations the scene has been changed from the Red Sea to the "Sea of Reeds" --which is a literal translation of the Hebrew phrase YAM SUF which appears in the earliest Hebrew texts. According to Manfred Barthel in WHAT THE BIBLE REALLY SAYS, "Whatever this Sea of Reeds might have been, it is clearly not the same as the Red Sea, which has never had reeds growing along its shores; its eastern shore, the Sinai Peninsula, is completely barren." (ibid p 113) (The author goes on to note that this is a very controversial topic.) --The Miracle of the Pillar of Fire According to Exodus 13:21, "the Lord went before them by day in a pillar of a cloud, to lead them the way; and by night in a pillar of fire, to give them light; to go by day and night." This "pillar of a cloud" sounds familiar to a large dust devil--a sand whirlwind that has been known to reach as high as sixty feet in the desert. Likewise, the "pillar of fire" sounds familiar to a flare up of a natural petroleum spring--which if true would be recognizable from a large distance. (Ibid, p 114). Others historians have noticed the similarity in this description with the appearance of clouds in the sky after a volcano has erupted in the distance. --Miracle of the Burning Brush There exists a shrub in Israel that is known as "the gas plant" or sometimes "the burning bush". Called DICTAMNUS ALBUS (It's Latin name) it grows best in warm dry climates and on chalky soil. According to Manfred Barthel in his book WHAT THE BIBLE REALLY SAYS," "Its sturdy rootstock sends up numerous stiff, vertical stalks bearing tough, dark green leaves that are shaped something like the leaves of an ash tree. The rose-colored blossoms--which look, appropriate enough, like miniature candles--appear in early summer. The entire plant is honeycombed with tiny oil sacs that secrete large quantities of volatile oils in hot weather. Direct rays of the sun may ignite the oil, which then burns off so quickly that the plant itself does not catch fire; in other words, it is not consumed. Visitors to Israel may have the opportunity to see any number of burning bushes in the desert if the sun is hot enough." (P 109-110) -- Turning of Aaron's rod into a serpent "And Moses and Aaron went in unto Pharaoh, and they did so as the LORD had commanded: and Aaron cast down his rod before Pharaoh, and before his servants, and it became a serpent. Then Pharaoh also called the wise men, and the sorcerers: now the magicians of Egypt, they also did in like manner with their enchantments. For they cast down every man his rod, and they became serpents: but Aaron's rod swallowed up their rods." (Exodus 7:10-12) In ancient Egypt, some species of serpents were believed to be endowed with great supernatural powers. Because snakes molt their old skin, and grow back new skin, they were worshipped by many ancient cults as symbolizing immortality. When Aaron's serpent devours the other, the author of these verses knows that this is symbolic that Aaron's powers are greater than those of the Egyptian magicians. (A popular magician trick of the time was to render snakes asleep/awake through the use of certain drugs.) When the Pharaoh is not convinced that he should free the hebrews (his heart had been hardened by God), God unleashed seven plagues on the countryside. Although there are no Egyptian records that verify that these calamities ever took place--still the nature of these pestilence plagues were not unusual occurrences in Egypt, (just as they were not uncommon in the rest of the ancient world). --The Miracle of the Branch that Made Waters Sweet In Exodus 15:25, we are told that "...and the Lord shewed [Moses] a tree, which when he had cast into the waters, the waters were made sweet ... " This miracle can be shown to any traveler today in the area, for Bedouin shepherds still use the branches of the barberry bush to make alkaline water sweet enough to drink. (ibid p 115) --The Miracle of Manna According to Exodus 16:14-5, the hebrew found manna (which means "what is this" in Hebrew) had been provided for them during their forty years in the wilderness: "And when the dew that law was gone up, behold, upon he face of the wilderness there lay a small round thing, as small as the hoar frost on the ground. And when the children of Israel saw it, they said to one another, It is manna: for they wist not what it was. And Moses said unto them, 'This is the bread which the Lord hath given you to eat.'" Professor Avinoam Denin of the University of Jerusalem has identified several plants (of the family Hammada salicornica)--all of them native to the Sinai peninsula, which secrete sticky-sweet droplets, after being punctured by insects. (Ibid, p 116) --The Miracle of God's Presence on Mt Sinai According to Exodus 19:18, "And mount Sinai was altogether on a smoke, because the LORD descended upon it in fire; and the smoke thereof ascended as the smoke of a furnace, and the whole mount quaked greatly." As many geologists would tell you, the above is an excellent description of the aftermath of a volcano eruption. Although there is no trace of volcanic activity on Sinai Peninsula, Moses could have seen such scenes when he lived in the land of Midian. (Ibid, p 118) Impact of Egyptian Civilization on the Greeks Being one of the oldest and greatest cultures of its time, Egyptian philosophy and religion had a major impact on other major civilizations-- notably the ancient Greeks. The Greek traveler and historian Herodotus (484-425 B.C.E.) wrote of his awe at the sight of the ancient pyramids (which were around two thousand years old and in ruins even by the fifth century B.C.E., when he was visiting them). According to Herodotus, his research on Egyptian religion convinced him that the names of the Greek gods came originally from Egypt--and that the Egyptians were the first to teach of an IMMORTAL soul which goes through a series of rebirths and deaths on earth. Plutarch (c. 46-120 C.E.) wrote how a number of Greek intellectuals-- including Solon, Pythagoras, and Plato-- had visited Egypt and studied their religious philosophies and rites. One author, Iamblichus (c 350-325 C.E.) wrote how Pythagoras lived in Egypt for twenty two years, where he studied astronomy and geometry, and was even allowed into the innermost sanctuaries of Egyptian temples to observe firsthand the initiation into the Egyptian mysteries. He later traveled to Babylon (he was captured as a prisoner of war) whereupon he studied with the Magii. Some twelve years later, he returned to southern Italy, where he spent the remaining thirty-forty years of his life. Although the Greeks were greatly impressed with Egyptian culture and knowledge, they differed with how the Egyptians conceived of their gods in semi-animal form. Instead, the Greeks viewed their mythological gods and goddesses in humanlike form--often with major character flaws and weaknesses. Other Greek philosophers (such as Plato) contemplated on the existence of a perfect spiritual God--who lived in the highest realm of the universe. In the next chapter, we shall trace the development of Greek philosophy and religion, and explore how its concepts had a powerful impact on both Judaism and Christianity.